Verification record
Every claim in this article was checked against the abstracts of the papers it cites, by a separate pass that was given those abstracts and nothing else. A claim marked supported carries the sentence that supports it, quoted verbatim below.
- References
- 14
- Claims checked
- 6
- Fully supported
- 3
- Checked on
- Nov 21, 2026
Claim by claim
Eight field pea genotypes were grown at one site in Ayodhya, India, over two years and two sowing windows, giving four environments.
SupportedMeta-analysisMeta-analysis
“this study was conducted at Acharya Narendra Deva University of Agriculture and Technology, Kumarganj, Ayodhya during two consecutive years 2023–24 and 2024–25 with two growing seasons i.e. early and late using a randomised complete block design. The stability analysis of 8 genotypes was performed across four different environments”
The abstract confirms that eight genotypes of field pea were evaluated across four environments generated by two consecutive years and two growing seasons (early and late) at a single location in Ayodhya.
Checked by google/gemini-3.8-flash on Nov 21, 2026
The study reports significant genotype by environment interaction and names IPF 14-13, Pant P-243, Pant P-200 and Pant P-347 as high-yielding with broad adaptability.
SupportedMeta-analysisMeta-analysis
“with strong genotype × environment interactions influencing trait expression. The linear component was high for most of the variability, while the non-significant deviation from regression indicated predictable and stable performance across environments. Stability parameters identified IPF 14-13, Pant P-243, Pant P-200 and Pant P-347 as superior performers, combining high-yield potential with broad adaptability”
The abstract explicitly notes strong genotype-by-environment interactions and identifies those four genotypes as combining high yield potential with broad adaptability.
Checked by google/gemini-3.8-flash on Nov 21, 2026
The same abstract also describes Pant P-347 and IPF-14-13 as specifically responsive to particular environments, which sits awkwardly with the broad-adaptability finding.
Partially supportedMeta-analysisMeta-analysis
“distinguished genotypes with broad stability, such as VL-42 and HUDP-15, from those with specific environmental responsiveness, such as Pant P-347 and IPF-14-13”
The abstract reports both broad adaptability and specific environmental responsiveness for these genotypes, but describing this contrast as sitting awkwardly is an editorial interpretation not directly stated in the text.
Checked by google/gemini-3.8-flash on Nov 21, 2026
The abstract describes the analysis as the Eberhart and Russell model of additive main effects and multiplicative interaction, though these are two distinct statistical methods.
Partially supportedMeta-analysisMeta-analysis
“The stability analysis of 8 genotypes was performed across four different environments to assess yield and yield related traits by utilising the Eberhart and Russell model of additive main effects and multiplicative interaction (AMMI) stability models.”
While the abstract phrases the methodology this way, it does not state that these are two distinct statistical methods.
Checked by google/gemini-3.8-flash on Nov 21, 2026
In maize tested across five locations, environment accounted for 25.12 percent of grain yield variation, genotype 35.20 percent and their interaction 21.18 percent.
SupportedUnclassifiedUnclassified. The study design could not be determined automatically.
“Analysis of variance indicated that 25.12% of the total variation in grain yield was due to environment factor, 35.20% to genotypic differences, and 21.18% to genotype by environmental interactions.”
The claim accurately states the percentages of variation in grain yield attributed to environment, genotype, and their interaction in maize tested across five locations.
Checked by google/gemini-3.8-flash on Nov 21, 2026
A wheat study found that different stability measures disagreed about which cultivars were ideal for which sowing conditions.
Partially supportedUnclassifiedUnclassified. The study design could not be determined automatically.
“Stability measurements, the additive main effects and multiplicative interaction model (AMMI) and genotype main effect plus genotype × environment interaction (GGE), were useful to determine the ideal genotypes for recommended and late sowing conditions (heat stressed). However, inconsistency was observed among some of these measurements.”
The abstract notes inconsistency among some stability measurements, but it does not specifically state that they disagreed on which cultivars were ideal for each sowing condition.
Checked by google/gemini-3.8-flash on Nov 21, 2026
What this does and does not prove
It proves that every DOI cited resolves to a real registered work whose returned DOI matches the one requested, that none of them is retracted, and that each claim has a named sentence in a cited abstract behind it.
It does not prove that the paper as a whole supports the claim. An abstract can overstate its own findings, and a sentence can be read out of context. That is why the quote is printed here rather than summarised: if the check is wrong, you can see that it is wrong.
Evidence grading is automatic and conservative. Anything it cannot classify is marked unclassified rather than flattered upward.