Verification record
Every claim in this article was checked against the abstracts of the papers it cites, by a separate pass that was given those abstracts and nothing else. A claim marked supported carries the sentence that supports it, quoted verbatim below.
- References
- 14
- Claims checked
- 6
- Fully supported
- 5
- Checked on
- Nov 13, 2026
Claim by claim
In a two-season field trial at Sriniketan, West Bengal, topramezone at 25 g/ha applied 25 days after sowing reduced chickpea weed density and weed dry weight and gave a seed yield of 1402.58 kg/ha.
SupportedField trialField trial
“A field trial was undertaken at Sriniketan, West Bengal, during the rabi seasons of 2021–2022 and 2022–2023 to study the performance of topramezone at different application rates as a post-emergence herbicide in chickpea cultivation. The experiment followed a randomised block design consisting of 9 treatments replicated 3 times, comparing topramezone (15–25 g ha-1) with standard herbicides, pendimethalin and imazethapyr. Results revealed that application of topramezone at 25 g ha-1 at 25 days after sowing significantly reduced weed density and dry weight, resulting in improved crop growth and productivity. This treatment showed performance comparable to pendimethalin (750 g ha-1) and superior to imazethapyr (60 g ha-1). European Weed Research Council (EWRC) phytotoxicity scores for all topramezone treatments remained at one across all observation intervals, indicating no crop injury, whereas imazethapyr caused transient phytotoxicity (score up to 4 at 7 days after herbicide application) that declined by 30 days after application. Higher plant height, leaf area index, dry matter accumulation and seed yield (1402.58 kg ha-1) were recorded under this treatment.”
The abstract fully supports the trial location, two-season duration, application rate and timing, weed reduction effects, and the resulting seed yield.
Checked by google/gemini-3.8-flash on Nov 13, 2026
EWRC phytotoxicity scores for all topramezone treatments stayed at 1 across every observation interval, while imazethapyr scored up to 4 at 7 days after application and declined by 30 days.
SupportedField trialField trial
“European Weed Research Council (EWRC) phytotoxicity scores for all topramezone treatments remained at one across all observation intervals, indicating no crop injury, whereas imazethapyr caused transient phytotoxicity (score up to 4 at 7 days after herbicide application) that declined by 30 days after application.”
The abstract fully supports that EWRC scores for all topramezone treatments remained at one across all intervals and imazethapyr scored up to 4 at 7 days before declining by 30 days.
Checked by google/gemini-3.8-flash on Nov 13, 2026
Topramezone at 25 g/ha performed comparably to pendimethalin at 750 g/ha and better than imazethapyr at 60 g/ha in that trial.
SupportedField trialField trial
“Results revealed that application of topramezone at 25 g ha-1 at 25 days after sowing significantly reduced weed density and dry weight, resulting in improved crop growth and productivity. This treatment showed performance comparable to pendimethalin (750 g ha-1) and superior to imazethapyr (60 g ha-1).”
The abstract confirms that application of topramezone at 25 g/ha performed comparably to pendimethalin at 750 g/ha and was superior to imazethapyr at 60 g/ha.
Checked by google/gemini-3.8-flash on Nov 13, 2026
In kharif maize, topramezone at 25 g/ha applied post-emergence after atrazine or pyroxasulfone equalled the weed-free treatment for dry matter, nutrient uptake and yield.
SupportedField trialField trial
“The maximum periodical dry matter accumulation, nutrient uptake and yield of maize recorded in weed free treatment but was on par with the application of atrazine @ 500 g a.i. ha−1 (PE) fb topramezone @ 25 g a.i. ha−1 (PoE) at 25 DAS and application of pyroxasulfone @ 127 g a.i. ha−1 (PE) fb topramezone @ 25 g a.i. ha−1 (PoE) at 25 DAS.”
The abstract confirms that in kharif maize, dry matter accumulation, nutrient uptake, and yield in the weed-free treatment were on par with post-emergence topramezone at 25 g a.i./ha following pre-emergence atrazine or pyroxasulfone.
Checked by google/gemini-3.8-flash on Nov 13, 2026
A separate chickpea trial under conservation agriculture at Raipur reported 1740 kg/ha seed yield and 79.42 percent weed control efficiency with hand weeding twice.
SupportedField trialField trial
“However, hand weeding twice proved to be significantly superior in increasing growth and yield parameters, seed and stover yield of chickpea (1740 and 2223 kg ha−1, respectively), net return (Rs. 54615 ha−1) and B:C ratio (2.69) as well as maximum weed control efficiency (79.42 %)”
The abstract confirms that in a chickpea trial under conservation agriculture at Raipur, hand weeding twice achieved a seed yield of 1740 kg/ha and a weed control efficiency of 79.42%.
Checked by google/gemini-3.8-flash on Nov 13, 2026
A nano-encapsulated topramezone formulation showed stronger growth inhibition of the invasive weed Cyclachaena xanthiifolia than free topramezone, and its biosafety testing used fruit flies, S2 cells and maize seeds rather than chickpea.
Partially supportedLaboratory studyLaboratory study. Shown under laboratory conditions, not in the field.
“biosafety assessments confirmed the superior biocompatibility of TOP@HLDP toward non-target organisms, including fruit flies, S2 cells and maize seeds”
While the formulation demonstrated stronger growth inhibition against Cyclachaena xanthiifolia than free topramezone and was tested on fruit flies, S2 cells, and maize seeds, the abstract makes no mention of chickpea.
Checked by google/gemini-3.8-flash on Nov 13, 2026
What this does and does not prove
It proves that every DOI cited resolves to a real registered work whose returned DOI matches the one requested, that none of them is retracted, and that each claim has a named sentence in a cited abstract behind it.
It does not prove that the paper as a whole supports the claim. An abstract can overstate its own findings, and a sentence can be read out of context. That is why the quote is printed here rather than summarised: if the check is wrong, you can see that it is wrong.
Evidence grading is automatic and conservative. Anything it cannot classify is marked unclassified rather than flattered upward.